Welcome to Mormon Stories, where we explore the complex and often controversial aspects of Mormon history, doctrine, and culture. In this episode, we take a deep dive into the polygamous marriages of Joseph Smith, examining the historical records, church sources, and academic discussions surrounding his 35 wives.
We begin by categorizing these women—underage brides, polyandrous wives (already married to other men), widows, and single women—while analyzing the church’s own admissions about which wives Joseph Smith had sexual relations with. Using primary sources, we examine the scriptural justification for polygamy, particularly Jacob 2:27-30 in the Book of Mormon, and compare it with the lived reality of early Mormon polygamy.
The discussion covers key figures such as Fanny Alger, Louisa Beaman, Zina Huntington, and Helen Mar Kimball—who was only 14 years old at the time of her marriage. We address the controversial “angel with a drawn sword” narrative that Joseph Smith reportedly used to coerce women into these marriages and analyze testimonies from figures like Emily and Eliza Partridge, Malissa Lott, and Sylvia Sessions Lyon, who believed Joseph fathered her child.
We also dive into the secrecy and deception surrounding polygamy, including Emma Smith’s resistance, hidden marriages, and church leaders’ efforts to obscure certain details. The Temple Lott Case and Brian Hales’ apologetics are also examined in depth. Additionally, we look into the actual children born into polygamy during Joseph Smith’s own lifetime.
Beyond the historical facts, this episode explores the broader implications of polygamy, including issues of consent, power dynamics, and the lasting impact on Mormon theology. We also touch on the lighter side—why we joke about serious topics, the absurdity of certain justifications, and how modern perspectives challenge traditional narratives.
Join us as we uncover the untold stories, challenge apologetic claims, and provide a well-researched, critical look at Mormon polygamy. Whether you’re a history buff, a questioning believer, or just curious about early Mormonism, this episode offers valuable insight.
Subscribe for more deep dives into Mormon history and culture!
