Join us for a compelling discussion with scholar Brent Metcalfe as he reflects on the 30th anniversary of his excommunication from the Mormon Church. In this episode, we explore his groundbreaking research on the Book of Mormon, including his famous discovery of the Mosiah Priority—a theory that challenges the traditional narrative of how the Book of Mormon was translated.
Metcalfe shares his journey from working at BYU to becoming a central figure in Mormon studies. His involvement with Mark Hofmann, the infamous forger behind the Salamander Letter, put him in unexpected danger and led to his protective custody. Despite these challenges, Metcalfe remained committed to studying Mormon history and doctrine.
One of the most significant topics covered is Metcalfe’s research into the Book of Mormon’s structure. He discusses the order in which the book was dictated, the inconsistencies in its narrative, and how these findings led him to question its historicity. His insights into how Oliver Cowdery influenced the text, the presence of King James Bible language, and the way Joseph Smith adapted religious themes add depth to the ongoing debate about the book’s origins.
We also examine the broader implications of Metcalfe’s work, including the controversies surrounding his book New Approaches to the Book of Mormon. The volume, which included essays from various scholars, was met with fierce criticism from apologetic organizations like FARMS. Some of its arguments—once considered heretical—are now being cautiously acknowledged by modern LDS scholars.
Beyond academic discourse, Metcalfe reflects on the personal toll of his excommunication. He speaks about the impact on his family, his struggle with living under the shadow of that event, and how his views on faith and belief have evolved over time.
Throughout the discussion, we explore other key issues such as the lost 116 pages of the Book of Mormon, the influence of the King James Bible on its text, and the evolving perception of the Book of Mormon’s historical authenticity within the Church. Metcalfe also touches on how modern Mormon apostles are subtly shifting their stance on the book’s historicity, signaling potential changes in LDS theology.
Whether you’re interested in Mormon history, scriptural analysis, or the personal journey of a scholar who has challenged mainstream narratives, this episode provides an insightful and thought-provoking look at one of the most debated religious texts in American history.
