In this episode, John and Gerardo dive into the fallout from a leaked audio clip of BYU Football captain and former Mormon missionary Tyler Batty’s fiery halftime speech, recorded outside the locker room at Mountain America Stadium in Tempe, Arizona. The speech, filled with explicit language, has sparked controversy, raising questions about BYU’s Honor Code, which strictly forbids profanity and vulgarity—yet Batty has faced no disciplinary action.
The controversy deepened when head BYU Football coach Kalani Sitake defended Batty, arguing that his actions were necessary for “helping the program.” Meanwhile, KSL, a media outlet owned by the LDS Church, dismissed critics, publishing an opinion piece telling people to “get over it” and rejecting calls for accountability. This apparent double standard has ignited a broader discussion about whether high-profile figures at BYU, particularly athletes, are given privileges that regular students—especially minorities and LGBTQ+ individuals—do not receive.
John and Gerardo break down past statements from LDS Church leaders, including clips from Elder Russell M. Nelson, Elder Dallin H. Oaks, and Elder Jeffrey R. Holland, who have all condemned profanity and emphasized the importance of upholding BYU’s moral standards. If the Honor Code applies to all students, why does it seem selectively enforced when it comes to a star football player?
The discussion also explores BYU’s history of religious exemption laws and its long-standing policies, including the prohibition of Sunday play. The show highlights real experiences from students who were harshly disciplined for much less than Batty’s actions—some even expelled for minor infractions. Through submitted stories, viewers hear firsthand how the Honor Code has been used against students in ways that feel disproportionately strict, particularly for those outside the mainstream LDS mold.
One of the key questions explored in this episode is whether BYU’s stance reflects a broader issue within Mormonism: the way male aggression, especially in sports, is often excused while other groups face rigid enforcement of rules. John and Gerardo examine whether Batty’s status as a returned missionary and team leader played a role in the leniency shown to him, in contrast to how BYU has historically treated students in less privileged positions.
The episode also delves into the ethical concerns surrounding the leaked recording itself. Was it wrong for someone—potentially an ASU security guard—to record and release it? Or does this exposure serve as an important window into the culture of BYU athletics?
As public debate around this incident grows, the conversation turns to the deeper implications for BYU, the LDS Church, and the broader Mormon community. Does this controversy highlight hypocrisy within the Honor Code system? Does it reveal an underlying shift in how BYU enforces its own standards? And what does it mean for students who have been disciplined or ostracized for far less?
Join us for this in-depth analysis as we unpack the many layers of this developing story and explore what it reveals about fairness, privilege, and institutional accountability at BYU.
One Response
Kismet! After listening to your story about BYU football. Look at what popped up on my instagram! “THE BYUJEW!” Might be a great Mormon Story?!
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DDKvW3QRyMR/?igsh=NTc4MTIwNjQ2YQ==