In this exclusive episode, we sit down with filmmakers Scott Beck and Bryan Woods, the creative duo behind A Quiet Place and Nightlight, to discuss their latest psychological horror film, Heretic. Starring Hugh Grant, Heretic follows two Mormon sister missionaries who find themselves trapped in a terrifying game of cat and mouse inside the home of the enigmatic Mr. Reed (Grant).

Beck and Woods share insights into what inspired them to explore Mormonism in a horror setting, the process of developing the film’s intense atmosphere, and how they balanced suspense with deeper thematic elements. From the real-life dangers faced by missionaries to broader questions of faith, power, and belief, Heretic challenges audiences to “question everything.”

The conversation also dives into the film’s accuracy in depicting Mormon culture, their interactions with real-life missionaries during the research phase, and the tension between men’s and women’s roles within the Church. They discuss how lead actresses—both with Mormon backgrounds—brought authenticity to their performances and how the film subtly critiques institutional power structures.

We also explore Hugh Grant’s chilling transformation into Mr. Reed, the creative decisions behind the film’s tone, and the challenges of making Heretic both terrifying and thought-provoking. Additionally, the directors address the LDS Church’s response to the film, their careful selection of quotes from former Church President Gordon B. Hinckley, and whether audiences can expect a sequel or prequel in the future.

With nine Mormon missionaries having died this year, Heretic sparks timely discussions about the vulnerabilities of those sent into the world in the name of faith. Whether you’re a fan of psychological thrillers or interested in religious commentary in film, this is a conversation you won’t want to miss!